Windoze Versus Mac - Feature by Feature

A personal view

High Tech Grunter

[!]

Let me first state that although MacOs is a piece of crap, at least it is a very shiny and sweet scented poo. Windows on the other hand is crap from the surface appearance (the aesthetic of the windows etc) right through to the underlying form (the core OS services). Read Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance for more info.

Other operating systems are actually quite good, such as Unix (Irix), AmigaOS, OS/2 (marginally good), and course, the delicious BeOs - an OS based on Media. The reason for this page is to remind PC users that Win95 still isn't good enough for wide-spread deployment; The product should be recalled, and users could reformat theirs disks to Linux or any other PC operating system would do nicely. At least if you run OS/2 or Linux your machine wont crash as often.

Space!

Okay, here we go:

1) Mouse update frequency and syncronicity.
2) Windows has many thousands more viruses.
3) The "facade" of Windows3.1 and then Win95.

1) Mouse update frequency and syncronicity.

On the mac, it depends on you monitor verticle refresh frequency (as set in the montiors control panel) and could anywhere from 50Hz (Only on my Amiga MacOs PAL emulation) to way up 70,80, 100Hz. The mouse is totally smooth and tracks beustifully as a result.

Unfortunately, Windows 3.1 and Win95 both have very dumb thing called a "software polled" mouse pointer update. The CPU sends the initiative to check the mouse using a pre-emptive time-scheduling facility (yes even on Win3.1 - it's called an interupt). But it wasn't synced to the monitor like the MacOS, Amiga Workbench, and The Atari Pointer, and as a result the pointer jerks and bumps across the screen. The software polled/timed approach is also used on X Windows (Silicon Graphics also suffers the same problem), WindowsNT, and OS/2.

An Example:

Mouse movement = 75 pixels
Screen Refresh Rate = 75 Hz

On the Mac:
1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, = smooth movement
On Windows: (assuming a mouse refresh of 51, which is good for windoze)
0.68 - a fraction comes out as
0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1 = jerky movement
0.68, 1.36, 2.04, 2.72, 3.4, 4.08, 4.08, 5.44 you get the idea, its very very jerky.

1. Shutdown Mac = Drag and drop mouse (special/shutdown)

TOP 1996 REPURCHASE RATES
Computer Brand Repurchase Rate

Apple Macintosh
Gateway 2000
Acer
Compaq
Hewlett Packard
Dell
81%
72%
69%
60%
58%
58%

Source: CIs Consumer Technology Index, 1997

[!] [!] [!]

Oops, I got bored with this page and forgot to finish it. But you get the point. For more on this topic try: WhyMac --------------------